Free Standard Shipping on Orders $79+

Free Shipping on All Subscriptions

Flat Rate Shipping $7.99

Bully Sticks Guide: How to Choose a Bully Stick

June 24, 2025 10 min read
dog holding bully stick between paws and looking to the left

 

Keeping our pups happy, healthy, and entertained doesn’t have to break the bank. Choosing the right bully stick for dogs starts with knowing what they’re made of and how they benefit your dog. This guide will help you feel confident selecting a chew that your dog will love and enjoy safely.

What Are Bully Sticks?

Simply put, bully sticks are a natural and easily digestible dog chew. They're made from a single, natural ingredient: beef pizzle, meaning they're free from artificial additives, chemicals, and preservatives. What you get is a tough, protein-packed chew that dogs love. And here at Best Bully Sticks, we source our prime-quality products from the best suppliers worldwide.

Can Any Dogs Have Bully Sticks?

Yes, most dogs can enjoy bully sticks, but there are definitely conditions to consider. When it comes to puppies, they can generally have bully sticks once their adult teeth have started to come in, typically around 3-4 months of age, and certainly once their permanent teeth are established and they are done teething. 

Choosing the Right Bully Stick for Your Dog

It's crucial to select an appropriately sized bully stick for puppies and always supervise their chewing sessions. No matter your dog's age, always keep an eye on them while they're chewing. You want to make sure they don't try to swallow a piece that's too big, and to watch out for anything that could be a problem.

What’s Your Dog’s Chewing Style?

When deciding how to choose a bully stick, understanding your dog's chewing style helps you pick the right one that will last and satisfy their needs:

Light Chewers

These pups take their time and gnaw gently. They're perfect candidates for thin or standard bully sticks that provide satisfying chew time without being overwhelming. Bully Bites work great for smaller light chewers, as well. Shop for light chewers here.

Moderate Chewers

Most dogs fall into this category. They enjoy a good chew session but don't attack their treats aggressively. Standard 6-inch or 12-inch bully sticks work wonderfully, offering hours of entertainment without wearing down too quickly. Shop for moderate chewers here.

Aggressive/Power Chewers

These determined chewers need something that can stand up to their enthusiasm. Thick, braided, or jumbo bully sticks provide the challenge they crave and last significantly longer than standard bully stick options. Shop for power chewers here.

Light Chewers vs. Aggressive Chewers 

For light chewers or those new to bully sticks, a thinner or shorter stick might be a good starting point. Aggressive chewers, on the other hand, will benefit from thicker, longer, or braided options that offer more resistance and last longer.

What Size Is Your Dog?

Size matters when choosing a bully stick:

  • Puppies: Once your puppy has their adult teeth (around 3-4 months), start with thin 4-6 inch bully sticks. These smaller sizes are easier for developing jaws to handle and won't overwhelm young chewers.
  • Small Dogs: Breeds under 25 pounds do well with 4-6 inch thin or standard bully sticks. Bully Bites also make excellent training rewards and quick treats for tiny pups.
  • Medium Dogs: Dogs weighing 25-50 pounds typically enjoy 6-12 inch standard or thick bully sticks. These provide adequate chewing time without being too large to manage.
  • Large Dogs: Breeds between 50-80 pounds need 12-inch standard or thick bully sticks to get meaningful chew time. Consider braided options for added durability.
  • Big Dogs: Giant breeds over 80 pounds require jumbo or braided bully sticks. The 12-inch jumbo size or braided varieties ensure these powerful chewers stay entertained.

Small Dogs vs. Large Dogs 

Small dogs often do well with thinner, shorter bully sticks, while larger breeds or power chewers will require much thicker and longer bully sticks to prevent them from finishing the chew too quickly.

Our Overall Recommendation

For most dogs, we recommend starting with our 6-inch standard bully stick. This versatile size works across multiple dog sizes and chewing styles, making it an ideal starting point. Small dogs will enjoy extended chew sessions, while larger dogs get a satisfying treat. Once you understand how quickly your dog works through it, you can adjust the thickness or length accordingly.

Shop our full collection of bully sticks to find the perfect match for your pup.

Choosing the Right Bully Stick for Your Dog

Graphic comparing types of Best Bully Sticks 6-Inch Thin Odor-Free Bully Sticks for dogs, labeled as thin, standard, thick, jumbo, and braided, available in 6 or 12 inch lengths.

Selecting the perfect bully stick depends on several factors, including your dog's size, age, and chewing behavior.

Types of Bully Sticks

Straight Bully Sticks: Our classic option comes in various lengths and thicknesses (thin, standard, thick, jumbo). Perfect for dogs who prefer a straightforward chew. Shop our naturally scented or odor-free varieties depending on your preference.

Three 6-Inch Odor-Free Bully Sticks (5 Pack) from Best Bully Sticks on a white background.

Braided Bully Sticks: Ideal for power chewers who demolish standard sticks too quickly. The braided texture also provides extra dental benefits.

A bunch of Best Bully Sticks' 12-Inch Braided Bully Sticks on a white background.

Curly Bully Sticks: These chews offer a fun twist (literally!) on the traditional stick. The unique shape allows dogs to hold them with their paws while chewing, and the curves create extra friction for better teeth cleaning. 

Three 10-Inch Curly Bully Sticks from Best Bully Sticks, known for being natural single-ingredient dog chews, are arranged in a line on a white surface.

Odor-Free Bully Sticks: We oven-dry our products and hang them vertically until they're free of odor-creating moisture. These provide all the benefits of traditional bully sticks without the strong scent, making them perfect for indoor chewing.

Three 12-inch thick bully sticks by Best Bully Sticks are carefully arranged on a pristine white surface, ready to serve as an irresistible dog chew.

Hickory Smoked Bully Sticks: Slow-smoked in our Richmond, Virginia facility, these premium smoked dog chews and treats deliver a mouthwatering BBQ-inspired aroma and rich taste. 

10-12 Inch Hickory Smoked Bully and Collagen Sticks

Bladder Sticks: A natural rawhide alternative made from a single ingredient. These 6-inch chews are highly digestible and ideal for small to medium dogs looking for something different.

A pile of Best Bully Sticks' 6-Inch Bladder Sticks on a white background.

Bully Collagen Sticks: Available straight, braided, or curly, these limited-ingredient chews support healthy bones, joints, skin, and coat. They're slightly different from traditional bully sticks and offer variety to your dog's chewing routine.

The blue package of Best Bully Collagen Sticks by Best Bully Sticks displays visible sticks, labeled as the "#1 Online Bully Stick Brand," promoting dental health and beef collagen benefits as a "Natural Alternative to Rawhide.

Bully Bites: Bite-sized pieces perfect for small dogs, training rewards, or quick treats. Made from the same high-quality beef as our full-size sticks, just in convenient, smaller portions.

A blue bag labeled "Best Bully Sticks" contains Bully Bite all-natural bully sticks for small dogs, with extra sticks shown in front of the package.

Extra-Thick: These are specially selected for their larger diameter, ideal for strong chewers.

Browse our complete collection to find what works best for your dog.

Benefits of Bully Sticks for Dogs

A quality dog bully stick offers a variety of advantages that go beyond just keeping your pup busy:

  • Long-Lasting Entertainment: Bully sticks are known for their durability, providing hours of engaging chew time for your dog. If you're a busy pet parent, you know how valuable this can be – it offers a great distraction and helps them burn off that extra energy.
  • Dental Support: Chewing is a natural and vital activity for dogs, and bully sticks can contribute to their dental hygiene. When your dog gnaws on a bully stick, it actually helps scrape away plaque and tartar, which means cleaner teeth and healthier gums for them.
  • High-Protein Content: Made from beef, bully sticks are naturally rich in protein, an essential nutrient for your dog's overall health and muscle development.
  • Mental Stimulation and Reduced Destructive Behavior: Beyond just being a physical action, chewing actually gives dogs some great mental stimulation. Providing a dedicated chew like a dog bully stick can help alleviate boredom, reduce anxiety, and redirect potentially destructive chewing habits toward an appropriate outlet.
  • Satisfy Natural Chewing Instincts: Dogs have an innate need to chew. Giving them a bully stick is a safe and satisfying way to let them chew to their heart's content, and that usually means a happier, more content pup.

The Difference Between Bully Sticks and Other Chews

It's helpful to know how bully sticks stack up against other popular dog chews. That way, you can pick the safest and most satisfying option that your dog will enjoy.

Bully Sticks vs Collagen Sticks

Both bully sticks and collagen sticks are single-ingredient, natural chews, but they come from different parts of the cow. Bully sticks are made from beef pizzle (muscle), while collagen sticks come from the inner layer of cow skin.

Bully sticks tend to be slightly softer and break down a bit faster, making them great for most chewers. Collagen sticks are typically harder and last longer, especially in braided form, making them excellent for aggressive chewers. 

Bully Sticks vs Yak Chews

Yak chews and bully sticks serve similar purposes but have distinct differences. Yak chews are made from hardened yak and cow milk cheese, while bully sticks are 100% beef.

Yak chews are significantly harder and last much longer, making them ideal for the most determined power chewers. However, their extreme hardness isn't suitable for all dogs, especially those with dental sensitivities. Bully sticks offer more flexibility and are generally easier on teeth while still providing substantial chew time.

Bully Sticks vs. Rawhide

Bully sticks are widely considered a safer and healthier alternative to rawhide chews. The problem with rawhide is that it can be really tough for dogs to digest, and sometimes it can even get stuck inside them, which could lead to blockages or choking. In contrast, bully sticks are easily digestible and crafted into totally natural, protein-rich dog treats.

Bully Sticks vs. Antlers or Bones

While antlers and bones can provide long-lasting chew experiences, they often have a much harder texture than bully sticks. Bully sticks, though, are a bit more flexible but still tough, giving your dog a satisfying chew that's easier on their pearly whites. Unlike some other options, bully sticks are also a single-ingredient, protein-rich treat.

Bully Sticks vs. Pig Ears

Pig ears are another popular chew, but their nutritional value and chewing duration can vary. Bully sticks are generally more durable and provide a longer-lasting chew. Best Bully Sticks also offers other natural chews like antlers and jerky.

How Bully Sticks Promote Healthy Chewing Habits

Dogs need to chew; it's just what they do! So, giving them the right things, like bully sticks, can make a huge difference in how happy and well-adjusted they are.

  • Stress Relief: Chewing is a natural stress reliever for dogs. That repetitive gnawing can actually be a big help in easing anxiety, especially for those pups dealing with separation anxiety or who are left by themselves sometimes. A bully stick can be just the ticket, giving them something comforting and distracting to really focus on, which can help them feel much calmer.
  • Teething Relief for Puppies: For puppies going through the uncomfortable teething phase, bully sticks can be a soothing aid. That gentle pressure and texture from chewing can really help soothe their sore gums and encourage those adult teeth to come in nicely. It's crucial to select appropriately sized and softer bully sticks for teething puppies and always supervise their chewing sessions.

How to Safely Serve Bully Sticks

Ensuring your dog's safety while they enjoy their bully stick is paramount. Think of it this way: giving a dog an oversized stick is like handing a toddler a sword—it needs guidance and care.

  • Always Supervise: Never leave your dog unsupervised with a bully stick, especially until you understand their chewing habits, as this allows you to intervene if the stick becomes a choking hazard or if your dog tries to swallow a piece that's too large.
  • Match Size to Dog: Always choose a bully stick that is appropriate for your dog's size and chewing style. A stick that's too small for a large dog can be swallowed too quickly, while one that's too large for a small dog might be overwhelming or difficult to manage.
  • Use Bully Stick Holders if Needed: For particularly enthusiastic chewers or to prevent your dog from trying to swallow the last small piece, consider using a bully stick holder.
  • Monitor for Wear and Discard When Small: As your dog chews, the bully stick will get smaller. Once it becomes small enough to be a choking hazard, or if it breaks into small pieces, it's time to discard it.

How Bully Sticks Impact Digestive Health

The natural chewing process supports your dog's digestive system by producing saliva that aids in breaking down food. Chewing also encourages regular bowel movements and helps prevent constipation. Unlike rawhide, bully sticks are highly digestible and break down naturally without leaving behind large pieces that could cause blockages.

If your dog has a sensitive stomach, introduce bully sticks gradually with just 10-15 minutes of supervised chewing initially. Watch for signs of digestive issues like loose stools, excessive gas, vomiting, or decreased appetite.

Bully Sticks for Special Needs Dogs

Senior dogs still have that natural urge to chew, and bully sticks help keep them mentally sharp while the protein supports muscle maintenance. For elderly dogs with weakened teeth or dental disease, opt for thinner bully sticks or softer collagen options. The repetitive motion of chewing can also soothe senior dogs experiencing anxiety or cognitive decline.

Bully sticks are also excellent for dogs with food allergies. As single-ingredient treats made from 100% beef, they contain no grains, artificial additives, or preservatives that might trigger reactions. Our bully sticks come from hormone-free, free-range cattle.

Where to Buy Quality Bully Sticks

When you're shopping for bully sticks, quality should really be your top priority. You'll want to find brands you can trust, ones that are upfront about what's in their products and meet high standards.

  • Clearly Labeled Ingredients and Sourcing: Reputable brands will clearly list their ingredients (which for bully sticks should be just one: beef pizzle) and ideally provide information about their sourcing practices.
  • No Added Chemicals or Artificial Preservatives: Quality bully sticks should be all-natural and free from any artificial additives, colors, flavors, or preservatives.

Why Best Bully Sticks?

We've spent over a decade perfecting our quality standards to give your dog the safest, most satisfying chews available.

  • Quality You Can Trust: We source from high-quality American or South American cattle that are hormone-free, free-range, and mature. We never source from China, and our products are baked right here in the USA.
  • Variety for Every Dog: From thin 4-inch sticks for puppies to jumbo 12-inch options for giant breeds, we offer something for every chewing preference.
  • Convenient Subscriptions: Our Subscribe & Save program delivers fresh treats on your schedule with exclusive savings.

Find the Perfect Bully Stick for Your Dogs Today!

Alright, with this guide under your belt, you're all set to confidently choose the perfect chews for your beloved dog. Your pup deserves a chew that’s not just fun but also safe and healthy. Explore options like best bully stick for dogs, power chewer dog bones & treats, or smoked dog treats and chews to find the perfect fit for your canine companion.

FAQs

What to look for when buying Bully Sticks?

When buying bully sticks, prioritize size and thickness appropriate for your dog's chewing habits, ensure they are sourced from reputable regions like the USA or South America, and confirm they are single-ingredient and free from chemicals, hormones, and artificial additives. Definitely look for brands that focus on digestibility and are super clear about how they make their bully sticks, especially if they oven-dry them for safety.

Which are the best bully sticks for dogs of all sizes?

For a versatile option that works across multiple dog sizes, consider a standard 6-inch bully stick. This length provides adequate chewing time for smaller pups while still being manageable, and you can always size up to 12-inch options for bigger dogs who need extended entertainment.

How often should I give my dog bully sticks?

General guidelines suggest giving your dog bully sticks a few times a week, perhaps 2 to 3 times, depending on their diet and activity level. It's all about moderation, really. And don't hesitate to ask your vet what the ideal frequency is for your dog since every pup's dietary needs and health are unique.

Are bully sticks natural and free from chemicals?

The best dog chews and bully sticks are indeed natural and should be free from chemicals. Best Bully Sticks, for instance, are made from a single natural ingredient and are oven-dried to destroy bacteria rather than being washed in chemicals. They are also free from added hormones and are sourced from free-range cattle. Always look for products that explicitly state their all-natural composition and processing methods to ensure you're providing a safe and healthy chew.


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in BBS Blog

Dog chewing on yak cheese chew
Are Yak Chews Safe and Good for Dogs?

December 22, 2025 4 min read

Himalayan recipes and offer a unique alternative to standard chews. But with any new treat, it’s normal to have questions about how safe it is for your dog.

Dog laying in grass and chewing on bully stick dog treat
The Best Treats for Keeping Your Dog Busy

December 19, 2025 4 min read

The best treats to keep dogs busy do more than just pass the time. They satisfy natural instincts, support dental health, and give your dog a healthy outlet for all that pent-up energy.

small white dog in grass with dog treat in mouth
Top Treats for Dogs with Sensitive Stomachs

December 19, 2025 4 min read

This guide helps pet owners find safe, natural options that support healthy digestion while still giving their pups something to enjoy. 

Product Title