Free Standard Shipping on Orders $79+

Subscriptions Ship Free

Dog Bone Guide: How to Choose a Bone for Your Dog

March 31, 2026 8 min read
dog laying in grass chewing on a bone

 

Let’s break it down and chew on the facts together (pun very much intended). If you’re a dog parent, you’ve likely faced the delightful task of choosing the perfect bone for your furry friend. But with so many options out there, how do you know which bones are best for dogs? This guide's going to walk you through picking out the perfect bone for your dog, so you can be sure they really enjoy their chew and get the most out of it.

Why Choosing the Right Bone Matters

The healthiest dog bones are natural, single-ingredient chews that support dental health by helping reduce plaque and tartar buildup through the mechanical action of chewing. They keep teeth cleaner and gums healthier while satisfying your pup’s instinctive need to chew.

The best options are long-lasting chews made from natural ingredients without artificial additives, preservatives, or chemicals. These include bully sticks, collagen sticksantlers, and Himalayan yak cheese chews. Each provides endless entertainment while delivering nutritional benefits like protein, minerals, and joint support. Be sure to check out our complete collection of chews to find the perfect match for your dog.

What Bones Are Good for Dogs?

If you're on the hunt for the healthiest dog bones, it's worth considering a few details, such as whether they're easy on the stomach, how tough they are, and if they really suit your dog's individual needs.

Here are some popular options: 

  • Femur Bones - These sturdy bones can withstand even the most enthusiastic chewers. While they do help with dental health, they should be given in moderation to avoid tooth damage.
  • Antler Bones - Long-lasting and rich in minerals, antler bones are tough and perfect for strong chewers.

What Are Good Bones for Dogs Who Chew?

Bully Sticks

Bully sticks are a crowd favorite for many reasons. These chews are made from nothing but the best beef muscle, which is why they're so healthy and easy for dogs to digest. Unlike rawhide, which can cause digestive issues, bully sticks are gentle on your dog’s stomach while offering hours of chewing satisfaction. They even help scrape away that plaque and tartar that can cause problems.

Collagen Chews

Collagen chews are another great option for dogs because they last a while and are easy to digest. It's not just about keeping them busy either. Collagen Chews help keep their joints feeling good and their tummies happy. Collagen supports digestive health, skin and coat health, and joint and bone health. 

Yak Chews

Yak cheese chews are a great pick for dogs that need something tough to gnaw on. These chews are based on a generations-old recipe from the Himalayan mountains and are made with simple ingredients like yak and cow milk. We make sure the lactose is removed during the process, so they’re much gentler on your dog’s stomach. Because they have a harder texture, they're perfect for those dogs that usually chew through everything.

Antler Chews

If you have a strong chewer, antler chews might be just what you’re looking for. Antler chews are natural and made responsibly, which is a bonus. They're also full of minerals like calcium and phosphorus, which are important for healthy bones. Antlers are extremely long-lasting, making them perfect for power chewers who need something tougher to gnaw on. However, they are best suited for adult dogs and should be avoided by puppies or senior dogs due to their hardness. It’s recommended to consult with your vet before giving them to a puppy or senior dog, as their teeth may be more vulnerable.

How to Choose a Dog Bone By Dog Size 

Choosing the right dog bone starts with your dog’s size, since their mouth shape, jaw strength, and chewing style all play a role in what’s safe and comfortable. Smaller dogs typically need lighter, easier-to-hold chews, while larger dogs often require more durable options that can stand up to stronger jaws. The goal is to choose a bone that fits your dog’s build and chewing ability, so they can chew comfortably without unnecessary safety risks.

  • Small dogs (under 25 pounds) need appropriately sized options like 2-3 inch femur bones, thin 4-6 inch bully sticks, or bully bites. These smaller chews prevent overwhelming their jaws while still providing satisfying chew time.
  • Medium dogs (25-50 pounds) do well with 6-inch standard or thick bully sticks, medium collagen sticks, or appropriately sized bones. These provide decent chewing duration without being too large to manage.
  • Large dogs (50-80 pounds) require more substantial options like 12-inch bully sticks, large antlers, or bigger bones. Jumbo femur bones work well for these dogs, giving them meaningful chew time without finishing too quickly.
  • Extra-large dogs and power chewers (over 80 pounds) need the toughest, largest options out there. Monster femur bones (14-18 inches), jumbo bully sticks, braided chews, XL yak chew, and large whole antlers satisfy their powerful chewing instincts. 

How to Choose a Dog Bone By Chewing Style

  • Light Chewers: These gentle dogs take their time and gnaw slowly. They're perfect candidates for thin bully sticks, standard collagen sticks, pig ears, or bully bites. Split antlers work better than whole antlers since they expose the softer marrow core. Light chewers don't need the toughest options and actually prefer softer textures they can work through comfortably. Browse options for light chewers here.
  • Moderate Chewers: Most dogs fall into this category. They enjoy regular chew sessions but don't chew treats aggressively. Standard 6-inch or 12-inch bully sticks, regular collagen sticks, beef trachea, and medium-sized bones work wonderfully. These provide hours of entertainment without wearing down too quickly or being impossibly hard.
  • Aggressive Chewers: Power chewers need the toughest options available. Jumbo bully sticks, braided chews, whole antlers, XL yak cheese, and monster femur bones stand up to intense chewing. These dogs demolish softer treats in minutes, requiring dense, durable chews that last. Thick or jumbo versions of any chew type work better than standard sizes for aggressive chewers.

How To Choose The Right Bones for Different Ages

Each dog has unique needs when it comes to bones. Here’s a breakdown of what works best for specific types of dogs:

Puppies

Puppies have developing teeth, so it’s important to choose chews that are soft and gentle. Look for soft chews or rubber bones that are safe for your puppy’s teeth. Avoid hard bones that could potentially damage their delicate teeth or cause pain.

  • 4-inch thin bully sticks - Small enough for developing jaws while still providing satisfying chew time
  • Bully bites - Bite-sized pieces perfect for small mouths and training rewards
  • Split elk antlers - Softer than whole antlers with exposed marrow that's easier on young teeth
  • Collagen rings - Gentle on developing teeth while supporting growing bones and joints

Adult Dogs

Adult dogs can handle a wider variety of chews, but the best choice depends on their size, chewing style, and energy level. Look for bones that are durable enough to keep them engaged without being too hard or difficult to chew. 

  • Standard to jumbo bully sticks - Match thickness to your dog's chewing intensity
  • Collagen sticks (straight, braided, or curly) - Support joint health while providing entertainment
  • Whole or split antlers - Long-lasting options for power chewers
  • Yak cheese chews - Rock-hard challenges for determined chewers
  • Femur bones - Natural bones with marrow that adult dogs love
  • USA-Baked treats and chews - Quality options baked domestically

For Senior Dogs

As dogs age, their teeth and gums become more sensitive. For senior dogs, choose softer chews like collagen sticks or dental bones. These options are gentle on aging teeth and gums while still providing the chewing benefits that dogs need to stay mentally stimulated. Collagen chews, in particular, support joint health, which is beneficial for older dogs.

Natural vs. Synthetic: Which is Better?

When it comes to dog bones, there are two primary categories: natural and synthetic.

Natural

Natural bones and chews represent the gold standard for dog treats. These single-ingredient options come straight from nature without artificial additives, preservatives, chemicals, or synthetic processing. What makes them superior? You're giving your dog exactly what they're designed to eat - pure, wholesome nutrition from real food sources.

Natural chews are easily digestible, breaking down safely in your dog's system just like their regular food. Eliminating the blockage risks associated with synthetic alternatives is an essential benefit; they provide genuine nutritional advantages, including protein for muscle development, minerals for bone health, and natural compounds that support joints, skin, and coat health.

Synthetic

Rubber chews or nylon bones are designed to be durable and long-lasting. However, they lack the nutritional benefits of natural bones and may not provide the same satisfaction for your dog’s chewing needs. Synthetic bones or chews can also wear down more quickly, posing a risk of ingestion if pieces break off.

When it really comes down to it, whether you go for natural or synthetic bones or chews depends on what your dog likes and what works best for them. 

How to Pick a Healthy Dog Bone or Chews

When shopping for dog bones or chews, be sure to look for these key characteristics:

  • Single-ingredient options: Choose bones with no additives, preservatives, or artificial dyes.
  • Vet-approved labels: Look for safety certifications and approval from veterinary professionals.
  • Size-appropriate: Ensure the bone is the right size for your dog to avoid choking hazards.

Before providing your dog with a fun bone to chew on, read our essential guide on some additional things to keep in mind.

What Dog Bones to Avoid?

Not all bones and chews are created equal. Certain types pose serious health risks and should be avoided entirely.

  • Cooked bones from your kitchen are extremely dangerous. Cooking makes bones brittle and prone to splintering into sharp fragments that can puncture your dog's digestive tract, cause choking, or create blockages. 
  • Chemically treated bones and chews contain synthetic additives, artificial preservatives, or harsh chemicals used during processing. These substances can harm your dog's health and offer no nutritional benefits. 
  • Bones that are too small for your dog's size create choking hazards. Always choose bones wider than your dog's mouth to prevent accidental swallowing. 

Our Favorite Bones for Dogs

Light and Small:

  • Bully Bites - Bite-sized pieces perfect for small dogs and training
  • 4-inch thin bully sticks - Just right for small breeds and light chewers
  • 2-3 inch femur bones - Natural bones sized appropriately for smaller mouths
  • Pig ears - Soft enough for gentle chewers while still lasting

Medium for Any Dog:

  • 6-inch standard bully sticks - The most popular choice for dogs of various sizes
  • Standard collagen sticks - Balanced hardness for moderate chewers
  • Beef trachea - Crunchy texture with joint-supporting nutrients
  • Medium whole deer antlers - Approximately 7 inches, perfect for medium breeds

For Aggressive Chewers:

  • 12-inch jumbo bully sticks - Thick enough to challenge power chewers
  • Braided bully sticks - Three sticks twisted for extra durability
  • Monster femur bones - Super-sized at 14-18 inches for extra-large dogs
  • XL whole elk antlers - The ultimate long-lasting challenge
  • XL yak cheese chews - Rock-hard protein-packed chews for determined dogs

Shop All of Our Bones & Chews Here

Dog Bone FAQs

How long should I let my dog chew on a bone?

Allow them to chew for about 15-30 minutes, depending on the bone’s size and their chewing habits. Always supervise to ensure the bone doesn’t break into potentially dangerous pieces.

What dog bones are the safest?

The safest options are natural, single-ingredient chews like bully sticks and collagen sticks because they’re easily digestible and won’t splinter. Just make sure to choose the right size for your dog and always keep an eye on them while they’re chewing.

What are the benefits of dog bones?

Chewing is a natural way to keep your dog’s teeth clean and their mind busy, which helps a lot with boredom. These chews also provide a healthy nutritional boost that supports everything from joint health to a shiny coat.

Can I give my dog bones every day?

Giving your dog a bone every day is fine, as long as it’s not too large or hard for their teeth. Be sure to rotate different types of bones to keep things interesting and to prevent overuse of any one type.

How do I store dog bones?

Store your dog’s bones in a cool, dry place. For raw bones, keep them in the fridge, and for dried chews like bully sticks or antlers, simply store them in a sealed container to maintain freshness.

Final Tips Before You Toss That Bone

  • Always supervise your dog while they’re chewing to ensure they’re safe.
  • Toss the bone if it becomes too small or worn down.
  • Rotate chew options to prevent boredom and keep your dog engaged with fresh, exciting treats.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in BBS Blog

dog standing up to get treat from owners hand
Dog Treat Guide: How to Choose a Dog Treat

April 28, 2026 8 min read

In this guide, we'll walk you through how to choose the right treats for your dog's specific needs, so you can stop guessing and start seeing your dog's tail wag more often!

Dog laying in grass chewing on a bully stick
Edible vs Non-Edible Dog Chews: Which for Your Dog?

March 30, 2026 4 min read

brown dog holding a large bully stick
What Are the Safest Bones for Dogs to Chew?

March 30, 2026 6 min read

Finding the safest bones for dogs doesn't have to be complicated when you know what to look for and understand your dog's individual needs.

Product Title